Summary
90 Day Fiancé: Love In Paradiseseason 4 star Shawn Finch has shown enormous growth during his time on the show, and he and Brazilian fiancé Alliya de Batista were set to be the season’s strongest couple. However, Shawn is now showing his true colors, leading to a decline in his popularity. Considering his strong start, Shawn is proving to be the most disappointing cast member in season 4.
90 Day Fiancé: Love In Paradiseseason 4follows couples as they pursue romance amid cultural and personal differences. Season 4 features four international relationships struggling to overcome financial, sexual, and emotional incompatibility. Shawn and Alliya were the most promising of the cast, displaying a dedicated effort to meet in the middle. But with Shawn’s controlling and dismissive attitude toward Alliya re-emerging, they are no longer working toward a healthy future.

20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Shawn Was Initially Mourning The Loss Of Alliya’s Former Identity
Early in season 4, Shawn and Alliya’s main conflict wasShawn’s difficulty with Alliya’s gender transition. Alliya transitioned after she and Shawn began their relationship.Shawn was mournful about the person he fell in love with, while Alliya was delighted to be living freely.Shawn’s resistance to accepting Alliya’s transition threatened to break the coupleapart.
Shawn finally had a revelation when Alliya gathered her friends to celebrate the happiness she felt in her new identity. Shawn realized the person he fell in love with was gone for good, and if he did not accept Alliya, he would lose her too. He decided to give their relationship another chance and support Alliya’s journey. Shawn’s ability to come around and see the importance of his partner’s happiness made their relationship appear the most genuine and healthy of the90 Day Fiancé: Love In Paradiseseason 4 couples.

Shawn And Alliya Were Heading In The Right Direction After Their Romantic Engagement
Alliya Finally Introduced Shawn To Her Family As The Couple Planned Their Next Steps
Shawn and Alliya appeared to be on track to have a bright future together.Alliya introduced Shawn to her family, who didn’t know she had been in a relationshipfor several years.Her confidence in opening up about her relationship is a sign of Alliya’s commitment to Shawn.
Shawn, too, was looking toward the future, enlisting Brazilian singer Anitta to help him propose. He and Anitta recorded a video where the singer presented an engagement ring. Shawn then joined Alliya’s family for dinner and played the proposal video. Alliya happily accepted, and the newly engaged couple began planning their life together.

Alliya Alluded To Shawn’s Controlling Behavior
The Couple’s Age Gap And Financial Statuses Create A Power Imbalance
Following the engagement, Alliya discussed moving to America to live with Shawn. She expressed concern about being completely dependent on him, voicing discomfort with the power that would give him.The uneven power dynamic is a recurring theme in Shawn and Alliya’s relationship, and the engagement brought their underlying issues to the surface.
The age difference between Shawn, 61, and Alliya, 25, means there will always be an imbalance between them. Considering Shawn is much more established in his career than Alliya is, the natural assumption was for Alliya to uproot her life for Shawn. However, Alliya was concerned that would leave her vulnerable.

Alliya didn’t want to depend on Shawn since she wasn’t as established in her career.
Shawn had also expressed questionable feelings regarding Alliya’s transition.He said he liked the person Alliya was before her transition, who was “scared” and lacked confidence. This was disturbing to Alliya, who wondered why her partner would not want her to be happy. The insinuation was Shawn disliked the empowerment that came with Alliya’s transition and preferred to be with somebody he could easily control.

The Revelation That Shawn Is Unwilling To Be Monogamous With Alliya Reveals His True Character
Shawn Is Not Willing To Respect Alliya’s Desire For Commitment, Despite Their Engagement
Following their engagement, Alliya made a revelation to a friend about her relationship with Shawn. Alliya explained that despite his proposal,Shawn was not willing to be monogamous. This was the first time she addressed that Shawn had other partners.Alliya was not happy about the situation, and rightfully so. She said she never wanted their relationship to be open, but she was “nervous” to talk to Shawn about it.
Shawn essentially blindsided Alliya with him not wanting to be monogamous.
WhenAlliya discussed her concerns with Shawn, he was not receptive.Shawn maintained he had never agreed to be monogamous, considering his relationship with Alliya was long-distance, and they went extended periods without seeing one another. He again brought up Alliya’s personality change, explaininghe has trouble being intimate with her because she is now “entitled” and “bossy.”Shawn shamed Alliya for even expecting monogamy, which is shocking considering he had just proposed to her.
Shawn’s insistence on keeping an open relationship without mutual agreement from his partner is a red flag. He is not willing to sacrifice his pleasure for the most basic element of being in a committed relationship. Shawn’s lack of regard for Alliya is disappointing, considering they had been the strongest couple on90 Day Fiancé: Love In Paradiseseason 4. Unless Shawn has a breakthrough, he does not deserve to spend his life with a partner like Alliya.
90 Day Fiancé: Love In Paradiseairs Mondays at 9 p.m. EDT on TLC.